El Quenepo

• One of the best fine‑dining options on the island, located right on Esperanza’s waterfront 

• Features top-notch seafood, meat, cocktails, and even vegan/vegetarian dishes 

• Redditors say it's the only place to reserve, and it's “easily our most expensive meal—but you get what you pay for”

Coquí Fire Café

• A much-loved Mexican–Criollo fusion spot in Isabel Segunda, praised for its carnitas, tacos, and blazing hot sauces .

• Reviewers rave: “You’ll need a reservation” and “Chef Jimmy is a very creative chef… mango-garlic cheesecake… simply incredible

Tin Box

• Mid-island gem offering BBQ and sushi with standout sides like cornbread and fresh juices .

• Ranked among the top options by locals and recommended for its location and menu variety

Restaurante Bili

• A comforting, longstanding spot on the Esperanza malecón, serving fresh seafood and classic dishes—a favorite for piña coladas and malecón views.

• Solid reputation: locals say “This was our overall favorite … absolutely delicious food, friendly service and a beautiful view”